Category Archives: Android

The Promise of Mobile HTML5

Posted on by
4

Less than a year ago it seemed like HTML5 was going strong. With Facebook and Linkedin adopting the technology to reach most of the screens on the mobile and on the desktop.

Linkedin had the better hybrid mobile app (HTML5 + native) and published a series of videos and articles about how they successfully did it with a team of “just” 5 developers.
Admittedly Linkedin app was really nice, but, after learning more about the internals of their app I’ve realized it wasn’t perfect.
For example the way they manage the application cache is not as good as the HTML5 app-cache that just works well out of the box. Using the term “it wasn’t documented” is not a good enough excuse, it was working well long before the debute of their app.
Also, their infinit scroll is just a not so infinit swipe, etc’

Anyhow, it appears that linkedin, similar to her bigger sister Facebook, ditched its mobile HTML5 in favor of native.
Linkedin senior director for mobile engineering Kiran Prasad claims are that there is not a good debuger and no performance measuring tool.
Firstly the debuggers are getting there every day (there are many more).
Secondly, profiling in the desktop and mobile Chrome will give you a general idea where memory is going. Profiling hybrid apps in iOS6 is also available.
I don’t think that these are really the reasons, they simply needed a stronger platform and HTML5 became too difficult to scale to their needs. That’s reasonable, mobile HTML5 is definitely not for everything.

Yet, the promise is still here – use the same code base and the same web development skillset to deploy for: native apps for mobile, browser apps for mobile, cross platform for the desktop (also outside of the browser), and so much more.

So why mobile HTML5 is not there yet? I’ll outline some of the main reasons here:

1. It’s not realy the same web development skillset
Well it is in a way, for the simple stuff it is still mostly HTML, Javasctipt and CSS. But, even for the simple stuff, things that works just fine on the desktop browser can greatly affet smoothness, battery consumption, memory usage, and eventually crashes, when used in mobile.
Every bit of code needs to be perfected in order to maintain the user experiance. Not even talking about specific glitches in specific versions and OSes.

2. Android – when it comes to HTML5 Android sux big time.
iOS had good HTML5 support from the get go. It reached full maturity from iOS 5 which is currently all that is needed to cover the great majority of devices out there.
Android on the other hand only reached HTML5 maturity with version 4.1 which is less than 25% and going up slowly. The notorious Android fragmentation is affecting HTML5 as well.

3. HTML5 apps doesn’t easily scale in terms of features
You needs to be vigilant about every piece of code that is added.
For example, adding just a small feature like an image or a text to every item in a list can greatly hurt performance.

4. HTML5 apps doesn’t easily scale in terms of crew
You needs to be vigilant about every piece of code that is added.
In order to deliver the promise of same code base in all mobile devices and in the desktop you firstly need that all of your crew will be highly proficient. Mobile HTML5 apps can easily be ruined.
Secondly if you want that code to be used in the desktop as well, you need a greater level of harmony between members.

5. Product ppl want stuff they see on other apps.
Some of these stuff are very easy to create nativly but are extremly painfull when created in HTML5.
Product ppl needs to better understand the technology that is used.

6. Native is not that hard to do
At the end of the day wrting native apps for iOS and Android is not that difficult, it’ll be easier than HTML5 in many cases.
It’s way more diffuclt to ruin the smothness in native UI though I see many apps that manage to achive that.
An avarage native developer can easily achive good user experiance.
When writing native you can get a way with poorly written apps. Even if you will make the UI render itself 10 times more than it really needs to, you can still achive good user experiance that will satidfy most users.

7. Peer presure, don’t be a chicken
Some idiot with a rooted and very old phone, will install Android 4.0 mod (worse Android OS for HTML5). And than will start to whine that things don’t work smothly.
- That’s not even a real phone, idiot.
Announcements from facebook and linkedin ditching HTML5 in favor of native lowers the moral of HTML5 supporters and help ”classic” developers that are intimidated by stuff like javascript to raise their heads.
What?! Can’t you write it in native what are you chicken – nobody ever calls me chicken (btw, this is how we’ll be in 2 years)
You will (almost) always have doubts about switching to native.

∞. It’s not over, it’s barely just begun
Don’t be let down by facebook and linkedin moving to native, it’s always depends on the type of app, resources and the kind of people involved.
Mobile HTML5 apps are deliverable and in good quality for some time already.
You will gain the benefits mentioned above of same codebase and skillset along with way better deployment model.
Done right, you can deploy new app versions like deploying a website. Without the need for approval, and without sacrificing much user experience.

The bottom line is that mobile HTML5 is here for somewhat long time already, but it’s not for everything and definitely not for everyone – yet.

HTML5 Mobile Apps – Injection Heaven, Security Hell

Posted on by
3

Three weeks ago Path.com was fined for stupidly stealing their user’s contact list and saving it onto their servers. Path’s doing was obviously wrong but I’m not sure that their punishment was really justified, needing to pay this enormous bribe to the FTC using COPPA as an excuse. The lesson here is to always comply with COPPA.

Anyhow, in that same techcrunch article you can also find that “The FTC also took the opportunity to introduce a new set of guidelines for mobile developers“. Although they explain early in that article that it’s not meant to be a guideline, I still feel they misses a lot.

When it comes to HTML5 apps even the simplest app can greatly compromise the user privacy and security. If we’ll take the FTC example of a simple and harmless alarm clock app, If that app is built using HTML5 its size and complexity doesn’t matter. All that is needed is one javascript injection that will pass thorough.

How will that code be injected you may ask – all that is needed is for the app to load some content from a remote server the simplest example will be the “Terms And Condition” page which is mostly loaded into a WebView. It can be a more “complex” settings, like choosing the favorite color or loading the saved alarms. Any kind of sharing will probably be way more open to be exploited, i.e. “share your favorite alarms”. Push messages might also bring malicious code. ETC’

The bottom line is that any injection of javascript will give an attacker a lot of control over the device, more often than not it’ll be persistant. HTML5 apps usually use the localStorage that is rarely flushed, and leverage native DBs and the file system. The “page” or webview is rarly refreshed, so even if the injection is not persistant it’ll be alive for a long time.
Things like stealing the user’s contact list and tracking the user location are pretty common. Enabled by default in iPhone PhoneGap for example.

It’s only limited by the native API that is opened to Javascript, generally it’s very open, even more than the PhoneGap default API. I know of at least 1 popular HTML5 app that opens almost all of the Android native API.

You see, Javascript is one tough beast – it can run almost anywhere.
Javascript was designed basically as a none important sidekick to the browser’s HTML, “it should not cause any problems by being poorly written and should fail silently and not interfere with the main thing that is HTML.” Seriously that how it was, we’re lucky it’s not case insensitive. I’m sure that back than some people though it’ll make it simpler and better.
So, Javascript will run in any dom element no matter how naive you may think it is, it will run in unexpected parts of the element without needing the <script> tag, i.e. onerror=”attack()”. It used to even run from CSS and from images, but we’re over that now asfaik in mobile browsers.

As opposed to that, it’ll take a very special case for injection to be able to execute arbitrary native code. You can make a native android app that will run anything – even get root, but I doubt that any legitimate app regularly download strings and run it as commands. (basically on rooted Android you can do exec(“su”) and everything else)

With Javascript the app does not need to be designed in any special way, an unsanitizes string will likely to execute.

These kind of injection are not the sole problem of PhoneGap based applications.
Any app that uses HTML5, even if it’s mostly native, any API that is opened to javascript can be leveraged by an attacker.

Phonegap (Cordova) has a mechanism to white list remote hosts which is really only effective on the iOS. It adds a little bit of security, but many apps anyway uses a wildecard “*” to allow all hosts. The wildcard is used by default in the phonegap cloud (saas solution to build phonegap apps)

As you can see the option for an attacker are enourmoe, all it needs is one vector of injection and there is an open path (no phan) to take over all of the devices of all of the users.

HTML5 apps that runs inside the mobile browser are also a nice target for injection attacks, althouygh it’s lacking most of the native api, there is still access to location in all mobile browsers. It’s less powerful for the attacker since it’ll prompt the user way more vigusly.
The Dolphin Mobile Browser implement the full phonegap native api, for example (which is generally a good thing), but it makes in-the-browser websites and apps more exposed to attacks.

So what to do than?!
- Sanitize sanitize sanitize all user input, server and client!

I Didn’t Wait for the iPhone 5

Posted on by
Reply

I was an happy Android user ever since the Nexus One came out (the One was the first decent Android, btw). Since than I used a few Android phones and never thought I will switch. Android is open, free, power to the people, and all that – but the fact is that the iPhone is still the best phone there is.

Last Android I used a lot is the Samsung Galaxy Nexus, it has an impressive 720 x 1280 pixels, 4.65 inches screen, and overall a very nice spec. But overall it’s a bad phone. I was totaly not impressed by it. It only become good with the Android 4.1 Jelly Bean update (only 1.2% of Androids). Google even use this phone in the Gelly Bean screenshots.

Developing mainly for mobile, I have an iPhone 4S laying around, I knew the iPhone is better but didn’t want to switch yet because I was used to the Android ecosystem, the great Gmail app and the way it sync everything nicely – this is  an area where the iOS is still lacking.

I always postpond it saying – I will switch with the iPhone 5.

But, one day it happened, I stuck my sim into the 4S and never looked back.The small screen got some time to get used to, but after a short while, you realize its qaulity is far superior than anything else.

When I first saw the leaked iPhone case I was a bit shocked – it can’t be only that, it’s exactly the same just a bit longer. If this is for real than Apple might be in trouble. Then I relized, it doesn’t matter if that only what we get, it’s still gonna be the best phone. The iPhone 4S is already the best phone, so any improvement of that is still the best phone.

Yeah, there is the note with the huge screen, and the S3 is impressive, but still these are niche phones.

Apple will not be able to go on forever with improving what they already have, they will have to reinvent the wheel – again. Hopefully that will arrive as well.

I’m still excited about every new Android version and device, but for now I’m on an iPhone.

 

Lose when you’re better

Posted on by
2

Microsoft was always used to win with inferior products. Windows was inferior to the Mac OS for many years and yet it dominated the market. Internet Explorer, the infamous browser, was the best browser for a few seconds in history when it triumphed over Netscape when both were at version 4. We still feel the stagnation it created since than being the most inferior browser ever since.

Lately Microsoft started to create better products and yet instead of winning they fail. Silverlight is better than Flash & Flex and yet it lost to it not being able to gain any significant market share (Flash is better than HTML5 but lost to it as well, but that’s a different story).

What worries me a bit now is that the truly impressive Windows 7 mobile won’t be able to gain any significance market share. Not yet saying that it’s better than the iOS (iPhone) and/or Android, but it is an impressive OS that didn’t just copy the concepts of the other two. It’ll be interesting to see what will come out of it.

Phones

Now the world is gone, Nexus one

Posted on by
5

My Nexus has finally reached it’s final destination. It travel all over the US and some other countries switched 5 hands, before ending at it’s new home, and into my arms :)

It was a lengthy and cumbersome process for one to order a Nexus one. I wouldn’t have imagined it will take so much. Special thanx goes to the special girl that coordinated the delivery.

In order to order the Nexus I had to use a proxy, as described in here. proxz.com seemed good enough. On my machine I had an issue with an anti-virus blocking proxies. Shutting down or uninstalling the AV required a password, so I had to tweak the registry in order to remove it.

I’ve paid for a 1 month US proxy from proxz, to go on the safe side. I didn’t care so much for my credit card to be stolen, anyway it’s insured. But for my google account I’ve changed the password, just in case. Loosing my gmail seems much more dangerous than loosing my CC.

I’ve pimped my Nexus with some ASCII art:

my_nexus_ascii

Beside a few tiny glitches it seems great so far. The new software update is immediately installed so I don’t have to suffer from a missing multitouch.

Many things to do now, need to play with openplug, though their best sample TweetMWC looks only OK. And where is that Flash 10.1 I was promised?